Levi KeswickKey takeaways:
- Kirkland Small Batch Bourbon and Maker’s Mark bring unique flavor profiles to the table.
- Kirkland Small Batch, despite its rougher edges, is a cost-effective choice for cocktail mixing.
- Maker’s Mark offers a smooth, balanced experience, well-suited for both beginners and everyday whiskey enthusiasts.
- Both bourbons provide value for money, but their ideal uses may differ significantly.
The Kirkland Small Batch Bourbon: Bold Flavours on a Budget
Kirkland Small Batch Bourbon, a product from Costco’s in-house brand Kirkland, brings a warm, punchy profile that is not for the faint of heart. The initial tasting notes of vanilla, rye spice, and oak promise a deep and nuanced experience. The palate’s powerful ethanol punch, coupled with the sweet corn, cherry, and liquorice, make it an intriguing sip. However, its relatively harsh finish might be off-putting for some.
At 103 proof, this bourbon is significantly higher in alcohol content than some might expect from a standard bourbon, leading to a warmer, more intense experience. While it might not be an ideal choice for those seeking a smooth, sipping bourbon, the makers mark costco price makes it a fantastic choice when you’re seeking a sturdy, flavor-packed whiskey for mixing.
Interestingly, Kirkland Small Batch Bourbon also boasts a relatively complex mash bill of 74% corn, 18% rye, and 8% malted barley. The bourbon is aged for seven years and is crafted at the renowned Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky, which lends it an added layer of credibility.
Maker’s Mark: The Smooth Operator
Maker’s Mark is a well-regarded name in the bourbon industry, renowned for its smooth and balanced profile. Tasting notes of cinnamon, clove, nutmeg, and almond invite you in, while the palate promises rye spice, caramel, dried fruit, and nuts. The finish is long and characterized by caramel and spice, providing a satisfying conclusion to each sip.
This bourbon is notably different due to the presence of red wheat in the mash bill instead of the traditional rye, lending it a sweeter, smoother profile with an underlying bready flavor. Although Maker’s Mark may not provide the punch required for some cocktails, its easy sipping nature and overall balance make it an excellent choice for those new to bourbon, as well as those seeking an enjoyable everyday whisky.
With an interesting mix of 70% corn, 16% red wheat, and 14% malted barley in the mash bill, Maker’s Mark is also unique in that it is bottled not based on age but when the tasters deem it ready. This typically falls between 6 and 7 years, further emphasizing the brand’s dedication to quality over arbitrary maturation timelines.
The Battle of the Bottles: Kirkland vs Maker’s Mark
When it comes to price, the makers mark costco price comparison puts Kirkland Small Batch Bourbon ahead at approximately $26 for a 1L bottle, while Maker’s Mark comes in at around $32 for a 750ml bottle. The value, however, is subject to individual preferences and intended use. If you’re seeking a solid mixer for punchy cocktails, Kirkland Small Batch could be your bourbon of choice. If you prefer a smooth, non-challenging bourbon for casual sipping, Maker’s Mark might be the one for you.
While both bourbons certainly bring unique offerings to the table, the decision ultimately boils down to personal preference. Those seeking a challenging, flavorful sip might enjoy the robust profile of Kirkland Small Batch. Meanwhile, those looking for a balanced, everyday bourbon might gravitate towards the smoother and slightly sweeter profile of Maker’s Mark.
Conclusion: Value is Subjective
In the Kirkland vs Maker’s Mark bourbon battle, choosing a winner isn’t simple. The ultimate decision lies not only in the tasting notes or the mash bills but also in the intended use, personal preference, and perceived value. Whether you’re a whiskey connoisseur or a bourbon beginner, understanding what each bottle brings to the table can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your tastes, preferences, and budget.
